Audiobooks Like The Sun Down Motel

Read more

Brittany Pressley and Kirsten Potter trade narration across this dual-timeline gothic thriller — Pressley handling one woman's investigation in the present, Potter reaching back to the haunted motel of the 1980s — and the effect is of two voices slowly closing in on the same terrible secret from different directions. The atmospheric horror quality relies on what each narrator withholds as much as what she reveals. All ten picks are narrated by Pressley, so if her particular quality of controlled unease worked for you in this, you're hearing that same instrument applied to different mysteries.

10 audiobooks for fans of The Sun Down Motel

  1. 1
    Little Secrets cover

    Little Secrets

    by Jennifer Hillier

    Narrated by Kirsten Potter

    ★ 4.60 ABR Score (229.1K ratings)
    ★ 4.21 Goodreads (220.8K) ★ 4.66 Audible (8.3K)
    More about this pick

    Marin's desperate hunt for her kidnapped son's truth gets psychological depth through Kirsten Potter's portrayal of a mother's breaking point.

    Start Listening → Get the Book →
  2. 2
    A Killer's Mind cover

    A Killer's Mind

    Zoe Bentley Mystery • Book 1

    by Mike Omer

    Narrated by Brittany Pressley

    ★ 4.54 ABR Score (77.1K ratings)
    ★ 4.22 Goodreads (63.7K) ★ 4.58 Audible (13.3K)
    More about this pick

    When forensic psychologist Zoe Bentley investigates three embalmed Chicago women posed as if alive, the FBI's darkest case gets personal fast. Brittany Pressley captures both Zoe's analytical mind and growing dread perfectly.

    Start Listening → Get the Book →
  3. 3
    Local Woman Missing cover

    Local Woman Missing

    by Mary Kubica

    Narrated by Brittany Pressley, Jennifer Jill Araya, Gary Tiedemann, Jesse Vilinsky

    ★ 4.53 ABR Score (825.8K ratings)
    ★ 4.11 Goodreads (790.1K) ★ 4.46 Audible (35.7K)
    More about this pick

    Three females vanish from a suburban neighborhood, then one reappears eleven years later with shocking revelations. The ensemble cast handles multiple perspectives across time with gripping intensity.

    Start Listening → Get the Book →
  4. 4
    Live to Tell cover

    Live to Tell

    Detective D.D. Warren • Book 4

    by Lisa Gardner

    Narrated by Kirsten Potter, Rebecca Lowman, Ann Marie Lee

    ★ 4.41 ABR Score (51.1K ratings)
    ★ 4.18 Goodreads (47.1K) ★ 4.51 Audible (4.0K)
    More about this pick

    Three narrators handle different perspectives as Detective D.D. Warren investigates a family massacre while a psychiatric nurse faces her own dangerous patient crisis in parallel storylines.

    Start Listening → Get the Book →
  5. 5
    Find Her cover

    Find Her

    Detective D.D. Warren • Book 9

    by Lisa Gardner

    Narrated by Kirsten Potter

    ★ 4.41 ABR Score (75.0K ratings)
    ★ 4.16 Goodreads (62.1K) ★ 4.43 Audible (13.0K)
    More about this pick

    Flora Dane survived 472 days of captivity and now hunts predators herself, creating a chilling cat-and-mouse thriller. Potter's performance captures Flora's transformation from victim to vigilante with unsettling intensity.

    Start Listening → Get the Book →
  6. 6
    All Good People Here cover

    All Good People Here

    by Ashley Flowers, Alex Kiester

    Narrated by Brittany Pressley, Karissa Vacker, Ashley Flowers

    ★ 4.40 ABR Score (371.5K ratings)
    ★ 3.82 Goodreads (342.8K) ★ 4.5 Audible (28.8K)
    More about this pick

    Crime Junkie host Ashley Flowers crafts a journalist's obsession with two unsolved murders twenty years apart in small-town Indiana, with multiple narrators heightening the investigation's intensity.

    Start Listening → Get the Book →
  7. 7
    Catch Me cover

    Catch Me

    Detective D.D. Warren • Book 6

    by Lisa Gardner

    Narrated by Kirsten Potter

    ★ 4.40 ABR Score (50.6K ratings)
    ★ 4.2 Goodreads (44.4K) ★ 4.44 Audible (6.2K)
    More about this pick

    Charlene Grant counts down her final four days, convinced she'll be the next victim in a pattern of murders targeting her childhood friends.

    Start Listening → Get the Book →
  8. 8
    Fear Nothing cover

    Fear Nothing

    Detective D.D. Warren • Book 8

    by Lisa Gardner

    Narrated by Kirsten Potter

    ★ 4.39 ABR Score (36.9K ratings)
    ★ 4.14 Goodreads (32.9K) ★ 4.52 Audible (3.9K)
    More about this pick

    Detective D.D. Warren hunts a serial killer who leaves red roses and champagne with his victims, but this case becomes dangerously personal when she realizes she's also being hunted.

    Start Listening → Get the Book →
  9. 9
    Love You More cover

    Love You More

    Tessa Leoni • Book 1

    by Lisa Gardner

    Narrated by Kirsten Potter, Katie MacNichol

    ★ 4.39 ABR Score (65.3K ratings)
    ★ 4.18 Goodreads (58.0K) ★ 4.42 Audible (7.3K)
    More about this pick

    State trooper shoots husband, daughter vanishes—Gardner hooks you with this impossible scenario then twists until you question everything. Potter and MacNichol's dual narration amplifies the mounting paranoia perfectly.

    Start Listening → Get the Book →
  10. 10
    The Neighbor cover

    The Neighbor

    Detective D.D. Warren • Book 3

    by Lisa Gardner

    Narrated by Emily Janice Card, Kirby Heyborne, Kirsten Potter

    ★ 4.37 ABR Score (57.9K ratings)
    ★ 4.09 Goodreads (52.7K) ★ 4.47 Audible (5.3K)
    More about this pick

    When a young mother vanishes from suburban Boston with only her four-year-old as witness, Detective D.D. Warren uncovers secrets that will make you question everything about perfect families.

    Start Listening → Get the Book →

Browse Related Lists

The Sun Down Motel Best Thriller Audiobooks Most Popular Thriller

How We Rank Audiobooks

Rankings are driven by listener ratings and review counts from Audible and Goodreads. Books with high ratings across a large number of listeners rank higher — a 4.5 with 50,000 ratings says more than a 4.8 with 200.

Unlike most book lists, we weight audiobook-specific factors: narrator performance, production quality, and how well a story translates to audio. A great book with a poor narration isn't a great audiobook.

We don't accept paid placements or prioritize new releases. These rankings reflect what listeners actually enjoy, not what's being promoted.

Rankings update periodically as new ratings come in and new titles are added to the collection.

Read our full ranking methodology →